PhD Orals Document: Querying Analyses of Collaboration

Submitted by:

Angela Okune

Graduate Student

Department of Anthropology

University of California, Irvine

October 2, 2018

To her committee members:

Dr. Kim Fortun (Chair)

Dr. Kris Peterson

Dr. George Marcus

Dr. Angela Jenks

Dr. Cecelia Lynch

To Be Submitted by:

James Adams

Graduate Student

Department of Anthropology

University of California, Irvine

November 2018

Introduction

This essay, submitted by University of California, Irvine Anthropology PhD students Angela Okune and James Adams in partial fulfillment of their requirements for advancement to candidacy, explores a more collaborative approach to the genre of the orals document.

This essay--designed, analyzed, and compiled jointly--looks at how science and technology studies scholars, anthropologists, indigenous studies scholars and feminist scholars, among others, have thought about collaborative formations across the research life cycle.

Angela has approached the document with a particular interest in looking at the variety of ways that scholars have understood and sought to address ethical concerns to do with qualitative research, especially that which seeks to be “open” to the public and more “collaborative.” How has “collaboration” been explored and theorized across scales and sites to realize more equitable/egalitarian ways to do research (as afforded by new technologies and scholarly infrastructures?)? What limits and challenges have been identified? What ethical considerations have arisen and how have scholars sought to address them? For Angela, this is one of three essays: a second essay looks at efforts towards decolonizing the African university here; a third essay queries Science and Technology Studies in/on Africa here.

James has approached the document with a particular interest in thinking about collaboration as “working with” and also working against varying interests and goals. He is particularly interested in understanding this in terms of political praxis and action.

Angela and James devised a shared analytic structure, which they used to jointly query a set of works (find the full bibliography here). They have also documented and reflected on their own collaboration here.

Collaboration Work Flow

Conceptual Framework: AO: This orals document is framed around Fortun’s conceptualization of discursive risks and gaps (Fortun 2012). Fortun writes that the contemporary Late Industrial period is characterized by complex conditions for which there is no available idiom, no way of thinking that can...Read more

Content Bibliography: Collaboration

Meta-Essay: Okune, Angela and James Adams. 2018. "PhD Orals Document: Querying Analyses of Collaboration." PhD Orals Document. UC Irvine Anthropology. October. http://worldpece.org/content/phd-orals-document-querying-analyses-collaboration/essay Sub-essays on Research Design Okune, Angela and Adams...Read more

PECE: Analytics, Structure, Discursive Risks & Motivations for Use

AO: These orals documents seek to understand the discursive risks (Fortun 2012) of relevant literatures for my project. How have scholars been thinking and writing about science and technology in Africa, collaboration, and investments into the African university? What is a structured analytic and...Read more

Angela's Project + "Collaboration"

This orals essay focuses on including a wide range of disciplines thinking about collaboration across different periods of the research life cycle. James and I decided to focus on collaboration within the research life cycle (rather than just collaboration more broadly) because for both of our...Read more

Angela Okune: Brief Research Description

Collaborating on Data: An ethnography of qualitative research data in Nairobi This doctoral research project examines how qualitative research data is produced, shared, and contested by diverse research groups in Nairobi, Kenya. Despite decades of research aiming to solve Africa’s problems and...Read more

Angela Okune: Brief Bio

Angela Okune is a doctoral student in the Anthropology Department at the University of California, Irvine. She studies data sharing cultures and infrastructures of qualitative research groups working in and on Kenya in order to explore broader questions of equity, knowledge production and socio-...Read more

PhD Orals at UCI Anthro

When a student begins a graduate program, s/he is not yet a candidate for a graduate degree. According to the UC Irvine Graduate Division website , t o become a candidate for a graduate degree, a student must complete certain academic requirements to achieve the milestone of becoming a candidate...Read more

Querying Collaboration Extended Narrative

This orals document looks at how collaboration has been analyzed across a wide range of disciplines including informatics, organizational behavior, economics, and anthropology. Studying how collaboration is discussed across these diverse epistemic communities has helped me prepare for fieldwork...Read more

Full Bibliography: Collaboration

Aellah, G., T. Chantler, and P. W. Geissler, eds. 2016. Global Health Research in an Unequal World: Ethics Case Studies from Africa . Wallingford: CABI. https://doi.org/10.1079/9781786390042.0000 . Appleton, Nayantara, Dominique Behague, Adia Benton, Betsy Brada, Thomas Cousins, Des Fitzgerald,...Read more

FOR COMMITTEE MEMBERS: Essay Feedback

Orals Commitee members are requested to use the form (link below) to submit any feedback response in your evaluation of the essays and candidate. The authors and advisor have drafted elaborative review questions to help guide your interaction with the PECE essay format. https://goo.gl/forms/...Read more